11 Comments
User's avatar
Travis Jonker's avatar

Problem: I read this book with first graders and now they all think I'm really funny. Feeling a lot of pressure to live up to this new persona. Considering retirement.

Emma Straub's avatar

10/10 substack post, 10/10 book, 10/10 text thread, that's a 30 overall

Selina De Luca's avatar

We are obsessed with this book in our house. My kids have asked to read it multiple times a day since we receive it on release day and now, instead of saying "bye" when they walk into school in the morning, they call out "Love you, mommy! You smell like a baby!" Amazing.

Bethany Fort's avatar

Can't wait to read this! Also, I would LOVE to hear your breakdown of the "game" in different comedic picture books.

Kat Bailes's avatar

Why yes I did buy futuristic sunglasses for read-alouds of this book in the library.

Aubree Nichols's avatar

My mom had a DYMO when I was a kid! It had such a satisfying “click” which I loved so I’d sneak it from her desk to label my brother’s He-Man figures. Sadly my mom didn’t appreciate “Smellator” the way my brother and I did.

Elayne Crain's avatar

I love that this book feels like the natural progression of the game-ified humor in "Guess Again!" -- one of our family's long-time favorites. :)

And since it's Daylight Savings, it's also reassuring to know the future is (at least temporarily) one hour closer, because I'm totally on board for calling the thing in the middle of our face a mushroom.

The Artist at Work's avatar

My boys and I got to enjoy the live reading of this at the Central Library here in Austin, and it was a TREAT! We are raising a new generation of Susan-thankers.

Hollyann Powell's avatar

Have now read this book out loud to our daughter and can attest she thinks we are very silly people indeed.

Clarkie Doster's avatar

My 5yo was having a moment when our preorder came in, and then he started reading the book aloud, and, yes, he did feel so smart and funny. He likes to know he's in control of things, so the moment shifted. I'm actually now realizing that I haven't read it aloud yet! It's his job!

Also: My 2yo through the monitor last night when he should have been asleep: "You smell like a baby!"

12/10. Thanks, guys.

Maxine Davies's avatar

Ok ok ok you’ve got me, I will be ordering it.